If boring is the business model, how do we resist it?
If advertising has systems in place to reduce uncertainty, how do campaigns avoid becoming staid? Ellie Bartlett, Executive Producer at CANADA Los Angeles, says that, while certain guardrails are necessary, the industry also needs to embrace risk.
Nobody sets out to make something forgettable.
Yet, across advertising, music, entertainment and culture, more and more work seems to arrive at the same answer. The same references. The same visual language. The same strategies. The same measures of success.
This is rarely caused by a lack of imagination. More often, it is the logical outcome of systems designed to reduce uncertainty.
We use data to understand what audiences responded to yesterday and, very quickly, it becomes a blueprint for tomorrow.
A brief asks for something disruptive, then measures it against something that already exists. We use data to understand what audiences responded to yesterday and, very quickly, it becomes a blueprint for tomorrow. Every frame is storyboarded, tested and approved before the work has had a chance to surprise anyone. Risk is gradually removed until the original idea remains technically intact, but emotionally unrecognisable.
Above: "Every frame is storyboarded, tested and approved before the work has had a chance to surprise anyone."
The problem is not that creative people have stopped taking risks, it is that creative industries have, perhaps accidentally, built processes that make the expected answer easier to approve. I am part of those systems too, and I understand the pressures behind them: budgets, timelines, stakeholders, and the responsibility of protecting a creative idea. None of that disappears simply because we want to make interesting work.
Before deciding what a project should look like, it is important to understand where the idea is coming from.
So, the question is not how to remove every constraint, it is how to work differently within them. How do we protect the integrity of an idea while making it open to collaboration, giving it room to breathe and evolve? How do we give directors the confidence to take risks while making sure they understand what the brand, or client, or agency intends to achieve with the campaign. ?
I do not have a definitive answer. But there are a few principles I try to return to.
Understand the idea
Before deciding what a project should look like, it is important to understand where the idea is coming from. What is the real intention behind it? What needs to be protected, and what is still open to interpretation? Creative integrity does not necessarily mean preserving every detail of the original execution. Sometimes it means giving the idea enough space to become something better.
When I work with directors, I want them to understand the heart of the project, but I also want them to bring their own point of view. To challenge what is already there. To propose the unexpected thing. To take the work somewhere it could not have arrived at alone. That requires openness on both sides. Supporting a director does not mean handing them a predetermined answer, but it does not mean leaving them without context either. It means creating a shared understanding of the idea, then giving them the trust and support to push it somewhere interesting.
Above: Originality is developed through conversation, disagreement and experimentation.
Question assumptions
Every brief contains assumptions: about the audience, the format, what has worked before and what success is supposed to look like. Those assumptions may be right, but they are still worth examining.
The most useful creative relationships are not always the ones in which everyone agrees immediately.
Originality is rarely an isolated flash of inspiration; it develops through conversation, disagreement, experimentation and a willingness to reconsider what initially felt certain.
The most useful creative relationships are not always the ones in which everyone agrees immediately. They are the ones in which people feel able to challenge an idea without losing sight of what made it valuable in the first place.
Data as a provocation, not prescription
Data can help us understand audiences, but it becomes less useful when understanding quietly turns into instruction. Strategy, research and digital platforms can all be tools for invention. They can reveal tensions, contradictions and overlooked behaviours - the beginnings of new ideas rather than evidence that we should repeat old ones.
The challenge is to use data without becoming governed by it, and to protect what makes an idea distinctive as it moves through increasingly complex systems of feedback and approval.
Above: Some of the most interesting outcomes emerge through accidents.
Room for discovery
Some of the most interesting outcomes cannot be predicted in advance. Instead, they emerge through instinct, accidents, unconventional thinking and the judgement of the people making the work. Preparation should support an idea, not close down every possibility around it. The goal is not to manufacture chaos or take risks for effect, it is to create the conditions in which directors and creative teams feel able to explore, while knowing the underlying idea is understood and supported.
Being boring is rarely due to one big decision. Usually it's the result of many small, reasonable ones.
Failure is sometimes part of that process. Not every experiment will work, but if there is no room for anything to fail, there may not be much room for anything genuinely surprising to happen either. In the end, the greater risk may not be doing something different. It may be continuing to repeat what already feels familiar.
This is not about celebrating disruption for its own sake, or asking creatives to simply 'be braver', it is about building relationships and ways of working that allow people to take meaningful creative risks without feeling that they are taking them alone.
Ultimately, being boring is rarely due to one big decision. Usually it's the result of many small, reasonable ones. Perhaps resisting it begins by leaving a little more room for someone else to surprise us.